Harbour Club and Reef Club sit side by side on the bay side of Gulf Shore Boulevard North, with what builder Parker Borelli told Gulfshore Business is "basically the same layout." Hurricane Ian's surge wiped out Harbour Club's first floor. Reef Club remodeled its first floor. Harbour Club's owners decided renovation wasn't worth it and sold the 1.36-acre site. Harbour House, a 14-residence project, is now planned for 1624 Gulf Shore Blvd. N.
Two buildings with the same plan ended in different places. That gap tells a buyer how this stretch of Gulf Shore Boulevard now prices. In an older Miracle Mile building, part of what you pay for is the land and whatever the association might decide to do with it next. The new homes rising on the sold sites sit well above the price band where most vintage resales trade.
The Mile, Site by Site
Gulfshore Business describes the Miracle Mile as about 1.3 miles of shoreline running south along Gulf Shore Boulevard North from Doctors Pass to Naples Beach Club, through the Moorings and Coquina Sands. The same report lists Bahama Club, Gulf Shore Colony Club, Harbour Club, The Mansion House and Park Place Club among the mostly low-rise buildings razed for new projects. Here is what the reported site sales and the projects replacing them look like:
| Former building | Reported site sale | Replacement | New residences | Reported pricing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bahama Club, 36 units | $102.6 million, 2024 | Olana, 1121 Gulf Shore Blvd. | 12 | From $30 million |
| Executive Club | $60 million in 2023, then $92.5 million in 2025 | 3300 Gulf Shore | 51 | From $3.7 million |
| Park Place Club | $30 million, May 2023 | 2020 Gulf Shore | Boutique, in redesign | Not published |
| Harbour Club | $17.5 million | Harbour House, 1624 Gulf Shore Blvd. N. | 14 | $6.5 million to $10 million |
| The Mansion House, 8 cooperative units | Not reported | Rosewood Residences Naples, 1601 Gulf Shore Blvd. | 42 | $12.75 million to $45 million |
Naples Daily News reported the $102.6 million Bahama Club sale to BH Group and Kolter in April 2024. Per Business Observer, the complex had 36 units. Divide the total by the units and you get about $2.85 million per unit. That is a gross site price per unit. It is not what any owner received.
Why the Land Outran the Buildings
The table above shows land value going up while the buildings on it lost value. In a January 2025 release, Kolter reported that the former Executive Club site sold to Youngquist Brothers for $60 million in 2023 and that Kolter then bought it for $92.5 million. No building stood on that site that anyone planned to keep. The roughly 54 percent increase was a price on dirt between the Gulf and Doctors Bay.
Kolter Urban President Brian Van Slyke explained the logic to Gulfshore Business. He said the Bahama and Executive clubs "were much older construction and kind of built right on the sand." He also said that after Surfside and the statute changes, there is "a realization of what it's going to take to bring these properties up to current standards," which "factors into the board's decision whether to make a further investment or to sell."
Borelli described Harbour Club the same way: "those were '60s units, so they were a little small and they had so much land that they weren't using." Developers aren't paying for small units in an old building. They're paying for the frontage, the acreage and, on the bay side, the boat slips. Lee Golub of Golub & Company said boat slips with easy Gulf access drew him to the Park Place Club site.
Harbour Club shows that this math doesn't always produce a big number. At $17.5 million for a site of about 20 units, the gross figure comes to under $900,000 per old unit. Vintage buildings on the Mile don't all carry the same land value, and the gap depends on things a buyer can see from the street: beach or bay, lot size against the number of units, and docks.
Where the New Homes Land in the Price Bands
Most of the replacement homes are priced above the band where Miracle Mile resales usually trade. The lowest entry point is 3300 Gulf Shore, with residences from $3.7 million and construction underway since early 2026. The rest start at $6.5 million at Harbour House, $12.75 million at Rosewood Residences Naples and $30 million at Olana.
The Naples Area Board of REALTORS' September 2026 report, released October 23, shows that split across Collier County outside Marco Island. Condos priced from $1.5 million to $5 million recorded 437 sales in the 12 months through September 2026, up from 308 the year before. Supply in that band fell from 11.7 months to 5.5 months. Condos above $5 million recorded 42 sales in both 12-month periods. Supply above $5 million rose to 14.6 months from 13.2, and the median price slipped 2.9 percent to $6.325 million.
Closer to the boulevard, NABOR's Naples Beach area covers ZIP codes 34102, 34103 and 34108. It had 564 condos on the market in September 2026, 21.3 percent fewer than a year earlier, with 6.4 months of supply. Countywide, condos sold for 94.0 percent of their last list price in September 2026.
Taken together, those figures fit the site sales. Every time a vintage building on the Mile sells, its units leave the resale pool that a $1.5 million to $5 million buyer shops. The homes that replace it mostly come back above $5 million. The countywide band covers far more than one boulevard, so the Miracle Mile can't explain all of it. For a buyer here, though, the pattern holds. Mid-band vintage units are getting scarcer, and top-tier buyers have more choices, new presales among them, that compete for the same beach. NABOR's September commentary also said new-construction sales were underperforming across Southwest Florida, with builders offering concessions and rate buydowns.
Reading a Vintage Building on the Mile
If the land carries part of a vintage unit's price, you're also buying into the association's next big decision. Reef Club and Harbour Club faced the same choice and made opposite calls. When we walk a buyer through an older building on this stretch, the market questions come down to that decision: how much land the building has for its number of units, whether it has Gulf-access slips, how close it sits to a site that has already sold, and what the association has recently chosen to fund. We cover the paperwork side in our primer on condo assessments in Naples high-rises and our Gulf Shore Boulevard buyer questions.
A new residence asks you to weigh different things: delivery timing and a premium price. 3300 Gulf Shore is targeted for completion between late 2027 and summer 2028. Van Slyke reported more than $60 million in hard contracts there by summer. Borelli expects Harbour House to take 20 months to build, with completion planned for spring or summer 2028, and Olana is targeted for fall 2028. Rosewood Residences Naples was scheduled for completion around the end of 2026. Details are on our Rosewood Residences page.
The Boulevard Around the New Buildings
The top of this market has set new records this year. Naples Daily News reported in March 2026 that a remodeled penthouse at The Regent sold for $26 million, a Collier County condo resale record based on MLS data. The same paper reported in June 2026 that the first condo closing at Naples Beach Club, at the south end of the Mile, came in above $20 million. At the Vanderbilt Beach end of the boulevard, the 128-residence Ritz-Carlton Residences, Naples received a temporary certificate of occupancy in October, according to an October 27 release. We follow it on our STOCK Residences page.
The street itself is also in planning. At a September 14, 2026 workshop, Naples City Council discussed conceptual streetscape plans for Gulf Shore Boulevard North between 1065 and 2150. Council favored near-term landscaping while staff assesses the infrastructure underneath and returns with a timeline. If you buy now, your purchase comes before both the new buildings and the new streetscape are finished.
Questions Buyers Raise
Does a vintage unit on the Miracle Mile carry hidden land value?
Sometimes, and the amount varies by site. Reported site sales ranged from $17.5 million at Harbour Club to $102.6 million at Bahama Club. Beachfront acreage and bay-side slips explain much of that spread.
Are the new projects priced against resales?
Mostly not. Only 3300 Gulf Shore starts below $5 million, at $3.7 million. Harbour House, Rosewood and Olana all start above it.
Which band is tighter right now?
In NABOR's 12 months through September 2026, countywide condo supply was 5.5 months between $1.5 million and $5 million and 14.6 months above $5 million.
If you're deciding between a vintage unit on the Mile and a new residence a few doors down, The Lickley Group can compare the specific buildings you're considering, starting with their sites, slips and recent association decisions. Request a Confidential Market Consultation.